Love Island USA Reunion: What Happened Between Kaylor Martin and Aaron Evans?

Kaylor Martin didn’t hold back during the Love Island USA reunion, and she had plenty to say beyond just shouting, “Fawk, Aaron!”

During the special, which began streaming on Peacock on Monday, August 19, Kaylor confronted Aaron Evans after he admitted to being less than truthful about his Casa Amour encounter with Daniela Rivera.

“I lied to Kaylor, straight up. I didn’t tell her the full truth. I put my hands down Daniela’s pants, I kissed her, I snogged her,” Aaron confessed.

Kaylor—and the rest of the cast—were stunned. “What? Why didn’t you tell me this two days ago when I asked you in our hotel room?” Kaylor demanded before unleashing her anger.

“I just spent the last three f–king days with you in New York, and you never mentioned this. Why do you keep f–king lying to me?

And stop love-bombing me. I can’t believe I wasted my entire f–king summer on you, Aaron. I never want to speak to you ever again.”

After calling Aaron “disgusting” and a “piece of s–t,” Kaylor asked her best friend Lv Walker to switch seats.

“I didn’t have the balls,” Aaron admitted when Kaylor asked again why he hadn’t told her sooner.

Despite their tumultuous relationship, Kaylor and Aaron had managed to reconcile after Casa Amour, much to the frustration of viewers (and Kaylor’s mom, who shared her displeasure in a lengthy Facebook rant).

They even left the show as a couple, declaring their love for each other.

“I’m 22, so I know I have a lot of time to fall in love, break up, fall in love again, and have fun before settling down,” Kaylor said on the “Viall Files” podcast in July, explaining why she gave Aaron another chance.

“It’s a huge risk with Aaron, but I’m 22, and I’m allowed to take these risks.”

However, after watching the episodes, Kaylor hinted at reevaluating her decision.

“I don’t want to end things because what Aaron and I had was true and real, but I feel like I gave him chance after chance,” she said on the “BFFs” podcast a week later.

“It wasn’t just about Casa [Amour]; it was more about him not taking accountability like Kordell [Beckham] did, which really hurt. The least I deserved was the truth, and I didn’t get that.”

The “BFFs” podcast was brought up during Monday’s reunion, with Aaron accusing Kaylor of “shatting all over him” despite his grandfather passing away the morning of the taping.

While Aaron argued that he was emotionally drained and didn’t want to ruin their recent time together in NYC, Kaylor made it clear she was done.

Following the reunion taping earlier this month, Kaylor announced to onlookers in New York City that she was “single.”

“I’m realizing my f—king worth,” she said at a cast panel at 92NY on Friday, August 16. “When you’re in the villa, you’re in a bubble. It’s not normal. It was very hard for me being in there. I did fall in love, and what you saw was very genuine.”